How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Discussões sobre Verbs, Nouns, Adjectives, Prepositions, Present Perfect, Simple Past etc.

Mensagempor pondedaniel » 24 Mar 2009, 15:27

Know how to use both but just wondering if there's a specific rule for using them.

wanna take it a shot?

thanks for any inputs

Take care,

Teacher Pondé
pondedaniel
Expert Collaborator
Expert Collaborator
 
Mensagens: 3074
Registrado em: 16 Fev 2009, 22:48

Re: How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Mensagempor Genildo schuina » 24 Mar 2009, 18:52

"How come" differs from "why" in that the word order of the question is the same as that of a statement. Compare:

You didn't leave. (statement)
How come you didn't leave?
Why didn't you leave?
Genildo schuina
 
Mensagens: 21
Registrado em: 23 Mar 2009, 19:21

Re: How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Mensagempor donay mendonça » 25 Mar 2009, 11:37

Hi folks,


Have a look at the examples:

A)Why did you buy that?=How Come you bought that?

B)Why did you miss the movie?=How come you missed the movie?


Good luck! ;)
Moderador do Fórum
Antes de enviar mensagens leia as Regras do Fórum.
Antes de perguntar faça uma busca no site, clique aqui e saiba como.
Avatar do usuário
donay mendonça
Expert & Moderator
Expert & Moderator
 
Mensagens: 16394
Registrado em: 15 Abr 2008, 00:47

Re: How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Mensagempor pondedaniel » 26 Mar 2009, 00:29

all righ guys but what I can't still find is about grammar..

anyway,

thanks for your time,

Teacher Pondé
pondedaniel
Expert Collaborator
Expert Collaborator
 
Mensagens: 3074
Registrado em: 16 Fev 2009, 22:48

Re: How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Mensagempor donay mendonça » 26 Mar 2009, 11:29

Hi Teacher Pondé,

Sorry,what did say again?
Moderador do Fórum
Antes de enviar mensagens leia as Regras do Fórum.
Antes de perguntar faça uma busca no site, clique aqui e saiba como.
Avatar do usuário
donay mendonça
Expert & Moderator
Expert & Moderator
 
Mensagens: 16394
Registrado em: 15 Abr 2008, 00:47

Re: How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Mensagempor maoliveira75 » 27 Mar 2009, 09:01

According to Macmillan Dictionary, 'HOW COME' should be used in spoken language. So, I guess this can be one difference in the use between HOW COME and WHY. But I want to make a deeper research about this and I hope I can add something else here.
maoliveira75
 
Mensagens: 6
Registrado em: 26 Ago 2008, 13:47

Re: How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Mensagempor donay mendonça » 27 Mar 2009, 12:16

It seems to me that you don´t need did when you use how come.


;)
Moderador do Fórum
Antes de enviar mensagens leia as Regras do Fórum.
Antes de perguntar faça uma busca no site, clique aqui e saiba como.
Avatar do usuário
donay mendonça
Expert & Moderator
Expert & Moderator
 
Mensagens: 16394
Registrado em: 15 Abr 2008, 00:47

Re: How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Mensagempor timphillips » 27 Mar 2009, 17:38

Hi guys,

I think Donay got the grammar point right in the first reply. (The need for 'did' is a consequnce of that)
And Maoliveira75 is right about the spoken language `rule`

Tim :D
"No gentleman ever has any money." Oscar Wilde ( No English teacher either - Tim)
timphillips
Expert Collaborator
Expert Collaborator
 
Mensagens: 682
Registrado em: 22 Mar 2009, 22:31
Localização: Ouroeste, SP

Re: How Come X Why: Quando utilizar

Mensagempor donay mendonça » 28 Mar 2009, 10:55

Hi Tim,


Thank you!


God Bless you!


;)
Moderador do Fórum
Antes de enviar mensagens leia as Regras do Fórum.
Antes de perguntar faça uma busca no site, clique aqui e saiba como.
Avatar do usuário
donay mendonça
Expert & Moderator
Expert & Moderator
 
Mensagens: 16394
Registrado em: 15 Abr 2008, 00:47


Voltar para Gramática da Língua Inglesa



Quem está online

Usuários registrados: Bing [Bot], DAIANA GIROTO, Daij, debora.tiemy, donay mendonça, Dourado, Elizeth Oliveira, Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot], juanpablorj, Majestic-12 [Bot], MarcosPB, pondedaniel, rdatorre, Tarcísio, vitor boldrin