''Have you ever'' pode ser respondido com o verbo ''Did''?
- Dita
- Membro desde: 15 Mar 2014, 18:45
- Perfil · 5 Mensagens
Eu posso usar como pergunta o ''Have you ever...?'' e responder com o ''Did'' ou ''Didn't...?
Por exemplo: Have you ever played the guitar?
R: Yes, I did.
Have you ever slapped someone in public?
R: No, I didn't.
E se não for do jeito que escrevi, como seria o certo para responder aquelas questões ali?
Seria usando o ''Yes, I Have'' e na segunda resposta usaria o '' No, I Haven't''?
Obrigada!
Por exemplo: Have you ever played the guitar?
R: Yes, I did.
Have you ever slapped someone in public?
R: No, I didn't.
E se não for do jeito que escrevi, como seria o certo para responder aquelas questões ali?
Seria usando o ''Yes, I Have'' e na segunda resposta usaria o '' No, I Haven't''?
Obrigada!
CENTENAS DE EXPRESSÕES DO INGLÊS
4 respostas
Ordenar por: Data
- Renato Baroli
- Localização: Fortaleza, Brazil
- Membro desde: 06 Mar 2010, 18:29
- Perfil · 1.4k Pontos · 185 Mensagens
O normal é que se responda usando o mesmo auxiliar da pergunta, então...
Have you ever played the guitar?
R: Yes, I have.
Have you ever slapped someone in public?
R: No, I haven't.
Usar na resposta um auxiliar diferente do usado na pergunta soaria, pelo menos para mim, como se você estivesse respondendo outra pergunta.
Have you ever played the guitar?
R: Yes, I have.
Have you ever slapped someone in public?
R: No, I haven't.
Usar na resposta um auxiliar diferente do usado na pergunta soaria, pelo menos para mim, como se você estivesse respondendo outra pergunta.
- PPAULO
- Localização: Rio de Janeiro-Brazil
- Membro desde: 21 Fev 2013, 23:49
- Perfil · 76.1k Pontos · 15k Mensagens
Agreed. If the question was "did you played the guitar?" Yes, I did.
"Have you ever played..." Yes, I have (or haven´t, if otherwise).
To me, if you are answering "have you..." .
You could say "yes I did played'' it would be thought as, "sim, eu realmente toquei."
It´s another context (DID here don´t mean "I have played" but "I really have played." (so, DID for emphasis.) and wouldn´t be advisable to leave "played" out, then.
You see?
"Have you ever played..." Yes, I have (or haven´t, if otherwise).
To me, if you are answering "have you..." .
You could say "yes I did played'' it would be thought as, "sim, eu realmente toquei."
It´s another context (DID here don´t mean "I have played" but "I really have played." (so, DID for emphasis.) and wouldn´t be advisable to leave "played" out, then.
You see?
- Marlon X19
- Membro desde: 07 Fev 2012, 22:55
- Perfil · 1k Pontos · 234 Mensagens
Just correcting your sentence Paulo.
It's ''Did you PLAY the guitar'' not ''Did you PLAYED the guitar'' and it's ''yes, I did PLAY'' not ''yes, I did PLAYED''.
It's ''Did you PLAY the guitar'' not ''Did you PLAYED the guitar'' and it's ''yes, I did PLAY'' not ''yes, I did PLAYED''.